Beyond the Reputation

The person is always more than the story we hear about him.

During those fifteen days in Bain, there was one conversation that stayed with me much longer than the workshop itself.

It was with a physically challenged Dhokra artisan. Before I met him, I had already heard several stories about him. People told me that he had killed someone, that he was dangerous and that he could not leave the village because the police might catch him.

Naturally, I was curious.

But when I finally sat with him and listened to his story, I began to understand how little we sometimes know about a person when we judge him through what others say.

The Man Everyone Warned Me About

Bain had a reputation.

Even before we started the workshop, people had warned us about the village. The dhaba caretaker at Amadubi had told us stories about people stopping lorries, robbing vehicles and creating trouble for travellers.

During the workshop, I slowly began hearing more about the people who lived there.

One person told us that the practice of stopping and looting lorries had become almost impossible. The drivers knew about the village’s reputation and would pass through at great speed.

But the reputation remained.

Another person told us that whenever a crime happened somewhere nearby, the police would often come to the village and pick up a few people. They would be kept in custody for two or three days and then released.

Sometimes, according to what we were told, it seemed to have become almost routine.

Whether they were involved in the incident or not, their names would come up because of the reputation attached to the village.

I found this difficult to understand.

How could an entire community continue to be seen through its past? What happens to people who want to live differently but are never given the opportunity to be seen differently?

It was during this time that I heard about a particular artisan.

He had a physical disability. People told me that he had killed someone. They also said that he rarely went outside the village because he was afraid of being caught by the police.

I was naturally curious to meet him.

Listening to His Story

When I finally spoke to him, I found him to be quiet and polite.

He did not give me the impression of someone who was aggressive or difficult to approach. I was careful not to make assumptions, but I wanted to understand what had happened.

After we had spent some time together, he began telling me about his past.

He said that he had been a good student and had studied at a local school. Later, he got admission into college. Since he had to travel by train, he would commute every day and return home in the evening.

One day, while travelling to college, a ticket collector came to check the tickets.

Like many others in the area, he did not have a ticket.

The ticket collector apparently knew that people often travelled without tickets. But instead of simply asking him to pay or get down, he began making fun of his physical disability.

He called him “langda” and continued making jokes about him in front of his college friends.

He kept repeating it.

The man told me that he became extremely angry and lost control. With the help of two people nearby, he managed to get up and hit the ticket collector.

The man fell from the train and died.

That incident brought his college education to an end.

He returned to the village. People advised him not to leave because the police might arrest him.

Over time, the story travelled and became part of his identity.

When people spoke about him, they did not speak about the student who had gone to college or the young man who had wanted to study.

They spoke about the man who had killed someone.

That was the story I had heard too.

The Difference Between Hearing and Knowing

Listening to him was not easy.

I was aware that a man had lost his life in that incident. I am not suggesting that what happened was justified. There were serious consequences, and nothing could change that.

But for the first time, I was hearing the story directly from the person who had lived through it.

I began to understand something that I had not thought about earlier.

We often know people through what others tell us about them. We hear a story, form an opinion and carry that opinion with us, sometimes without ever meeting the person.

A person becomes a criminal, a difficult man, a dangerous person or someone who cannot be trusted.

We rarely ask what happened before that.

We rarely try to understand the circumstances, the life they have lived or the experiences that have shaped them.

And once a person gets labelled, it becomes very difficult to move away from that label.

I wondered how many times this man had tried to explain himself. How many people had actually sat down and listened to him? How many had bothered to see anything beyond that one incident?

Perhaps he had stopped explaining because nobody was interested in listening.

When Reputation Becomes an Identity

As I spent more time in Bain, I began to notice something about the community.

They were very poor. Their living conditions were difficult, and they had very few opportunities. Yet they were constantly being seen through their reputation.

Their past seemed to follow them wherever they went.

I don’t know how much of that reputation was true for each individual. There may have been people who had been involved in wrongdoing, and there may have been people who had nothing to do with it.

But the problem was that everyone seemed to be treated as though they belonged to the same category.

I started thinking about how this happens in many places.

We often make up our minds about people before meeting them. We hear something about a village, a community or a family and carry that opinion into every interaction.

Once we do that, we stop looking at the person in front of us. We only look for things that confirm what we have already heard.

The experience in Bain made me question this habit.

What Changed in Me

I went to Bain with a certain amount of fear because of what I had heard. The people there were also suspicious of us because we were outsiders.

But after spending time together, we began to understand each other a little better.

I realised that people cannot be understood from a distance. We have to spend time with them, listen to them and allow them to tell their own stories.

That does not mean accepting everything a person says or ignoring what has happened. It simply means not reducing a human being to one incident or one description.

I have carried this thought into my work ever since.

When I enter a village or begin working with a new community, I try not to arrive with too many opinions about the people. I may hear stories, warnings and suggestions from others, but I remind myself that these are only one person’s understanding.

The people themselves may have a very different story to tell.

I have also become more conscious of how easily we use labels. We call people difficult, uncooperative, uneducated or unwilling to change. But have we spent enough time understanding why they behave the way they do?

Sometimes, what we call resistance may come from years of disappointment. What we call arrogance may be a response to being looked down upon. What we call disinterest may simply be a lack of trust.

We cannot know unless we make the effort to listen.

I still think about that man in Bain. I don’t know what happened to him after the workshop, or whether his circumstances changed.

But I remember the conversation and how differently I looked at him after hearing his story.

We often form an opinion about a person after hearing a few sentences about his life. But it may take hours of sitting together to understand even a small part of who that person really is.

That, perhaps, was the most important thing Bain taught me.

A person is always more than the story we hear about him. And sometimes, all it takes to discover that is the willingness to sit down and listen.

Next
Next

The Fifteen Days in Bain